When it comes to strength training, one of the most debated topics among athletes, coaches, and researchers is whether you should push every set to failure or leave a few reps in reserve (RIR). While training to failure can seem like the ultimate test of effort, the science suggests that leaving a bit in the tank might actually be the smarter choice for building strength.
What Does Training to Failure Mean?
Training to failure involves performing repetitions until you can no longer complete another one with proper form. It’s often associated with maximum muscle activation and a feeling of intense accomplishment. However, pushing to failure every set isn’t always the most effective approach for building strength.
The Case for Leaving Reps in Reserve
Leaving 1–2 reps in reserve means stopping a set when you still feel like you could complete a few more reps without compromising form. Here’s why this method may be better for strength training:
- Improved Training Volume: Research shows that avoiding failure allows you to perform more total volume during a workout. Since training volume (sets × reps × weight) is a key driver of strength gains, this is a major advantage.
- Better Recovery: Training to failure increases fatigue and recovery time. By leaving reps in the tank, you can recover faster between sets and sessions, enabling more frequent and consistent training.
- Higher Quality of Movement: As you approach failure, your form may break down, increasing the risk of injury. Stopping a set with a few reps left ensures that every rep is performed with proper technique.
- Maximized Strength Gains: Studies have shown that leaving 1–2 reps in reserve provides similar or even greater strength improvements compared to training to failure, without the added fatigue.
What the Research Says
- Robinson et al. (2023): This study found that athletes who stopped sets with 1–2 reps in reserve experienced greater strength gains in exercises like the bench press and squat compared to those who trained to failure.
- Vieira et al. (2021): A systematic review concluded that non-failure training is as effective as training to failure for improving strength, but with less fatigue and faster recovery.
- Sampson and Groeller (2015): Their research indicated that leaving reps in the tank during high-load training was as effective for muscle hypertrophy as training to failure, suggesting similar benefits for strength development.
Practical Tips for Strength Training
- Use RIR: Aim to stop sets with 1–2 reps in reserve, especially for compound lifts like squats, deadlifts, and bench presses. This approach helps you maintain high training quality over time.
- Monitor Progression: Gradually increase the weight or reps over time to ensure you’re applying progressive overload without unnecessary fatigue.
- Autoregulation: Adjust your effort based on how you feel on a given day. If you’re feeling strong, you might push closer to failure. If you’re fatigued, leave more reps in the tank.
- Plan for Recovery: Include rest days and deload weeks in your training program to manage fatigue and promote long-term progress.
When to Train to Failure
While leaving reps in reserve is generally more effective for strength training, there are situations where training to failure can be beneficial:
- Accessory Movements: Exercises like bicep curls or tricep extensions can be taken to failure since they involve smaller muscle groups and less systemic fatigue.
- Advanced Lifters: Experienced athletes might use failure sparingly to push past plateaus or during peaking phases of a program.
- Occasional Testing: Use failure to gauge progress or test your limits, but avoid making it a regular part of your routine.
Conclusion
If your goal is to build strength, the evidence is clear: you don’t need to train to failure to achieve great results. Leaving a few reps in the tank allows you to train with higher volume, recover faster, and progress consistently over time. Save failure for the occasional test or accessory work, and focus on sustainable, high-quality training for long-term success.
By balancing effort with smart programming, you’ll not only get stronger but also reduce the risk of burnout and injury. So next time you’re in the gym, remember: strength isn’t just about how hard you push—it’s about how smart you train.
Check out Blog – Flex Affect for all things performance!
Challenge the standard!
